Skip to content

State Farm® Insurance Agent Joseph Benincasa

54 Willow Park Center
Farmingdale, NY 11735

Across from Farmingdale College - Located in the Target Shopping Center on Route 110

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Joseph Benincasa

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info


54 Willow Park Center
Farmingdale, NY 11735


English, Spanish, French
About Me

Contact us today for a free auto insurance quote!

Welcome to the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency! My team and I have a deep commitment to serving the principal interests of our customers by helping them find the perfect auto insurance, homeowners insurance, life insurance, renters insurance or boat insurance that suits their needs. My team of licensed insurance professionals are warm, friendly and knowledgeable and will always put the needs of the customer first. We treat each person like a family member and you will get a smile whether in person or over the phone every time. If you call the office during regular business hours, a live person will answer the phone and never a recording. We have earned our reputation through hard work, commitment, integrity, passion and consistency which is why customers remain loyal and take great comfort in referring us to their loved ones. We are also very committed to helping our community, other local businesses and non for profit organizations including This is My Swag and the Babylon Animal Shelter.

I have been married to my wife, Joanne, since 1989 and together we have two sons, Joseph and Matthew. Prior to joining State Farm, I was a pediatric rehabilitation professional for twenty years during which time I took care of children with disabilities. I was able to combine both my life experiences and true desire to make a difference in the lives of others and convert them into the State Farm world. In December 2009, I opened the doors to my first State Farm Agency in Hampton Bays, NY. Two years later, an agency opportunity presented itself in my neighboring town of Farmingdale, NY and I was selected to open and serve in this great community. I am a proud member of both the Farmingdale Chamber of Commerce and the East Farmingdale Kiwanis Club.

Our team of skilled insurance professionals will work with you to understand your needs and custom design a policy that fits your budget for any of the following:

· Car Insurance

· Life Insurance – Term, Whole and Universal

· Health Insurance – Hospital Income, Short Term and Long Term DBL

· Homeowners Insurance, Renters Insurance, Condo/Co-op Insurance

· Personal Article Policy

· Personal Liability Umbrella Policy

· Small Business Owner Insurance

· Business Owner Liability Insurance

· Commercial Liability Umbrella Policy

· Commercial Auto Insurance – Individual and Fleet

· Worker’s Compensation Insurance


· Insurance and Financial Services

· Recreational Vehicles: Motorcycle, Antique Car, Boat, Camper, ATV, Snow Mobile, Jet-ski

· FEMA Flood Insurance

· Pet Insurance

We are conveniently located in the Target Shopping Center on Rt. 110 in Farmingdale directly across from Farmingdale State College. Our service area includes all of New York State - the Bronx, Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queens, Staten Island, Nassau County, Suffolk County, Upstate and Westchester. We are thrilled to say that we also offer services in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Vermont. My dedicated State Farm team members provide bilingual services in Spanish and French and notary public services are offered by appointment.

Protect yourself and your family from risks and take action to achieve your goals today! If you would like to compare costs or simply get a no obligation free quote, call, click or stop in to speak with me or a member of my team! We would love to meet you and to help you with any insurance question you may have. You can also start a FREE quote online at


Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health, Pet

Other Products Offered

Banking, Mutual Funds, Annuities

Social Media
Skip Infinite Scroll Facebook Feed

At the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency our mission is to listen to the needs of our customers and provide them with auto insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance and life insurance options so that they may protect their loved ones and valued possessions. Our team of professionals is here and dedicated to provide prompt, courteous and efficient customer service. We build relationships through communication, honesty and integrity. It is our goal every day to earn your trust and business by offering the correct balance of product, price and service.

We service Farmingdale, the surrounding areas and all of New York State which includes Nassau County, Suffolk County, Westchester County, Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, Staten Island, the Bronx, Upstate and Westchester. We are thrilled to say that we also offer services in New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and Vermont.

My team of licensed insurance professionals provides warm, friendly, and efficient customer service. Our five star Google reviews are a testament to this. As life changes, so does your insurance and financial needs. Call, click or stop in today for a personalized review of your insurance policies and while you’re here we’ll take a picture of you and Jake!

Andrea DiBernardo State Farm Agent Team Member

Andrea DiBernardo

Office Manager

Andrea has been a very valuable team member of the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency since 2014. As a graduate of Hofstra University’s Business Program where she earned the prestigious honor of Summa Cum Laude, Andrea began her career with us as an unlicensed team member and quickly earned her full Property and Casualty and Life/Accident and Health licenses. While working with our current customer base here in Farmingdale, Andrea displayed a talent in helping new customers acclimate to our agency. In 2017 Andrea’s strong people and leadership skills led to her to the promotion of Office Manager. Andrea loves working with her fellow team members and believes that her strengths lie in quoting and binding new business for personal insurance and commercial insurance. She is also the proud mamma of our agency mascot, Buddy.

John Stevens State Farm Agent Team Member

John Stevens

Account Associate

John became a team member of the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency in July 2020. As a childhood friend of Joe’s from Franklin Square, NY and with over 30 years of experience in the automobile insurance and homeowner's insurance world, John is a licensed Property and Casualty Account Associate. As a valuable resource to the team, John is there to help you and your family manage your risks and prepare for the unexpected. John loves the positive office environment, working with his caring teammates, as well as the customer service policy employed by the agency which is to always put the insurance needs of the customer first.

Pete Aleman State Farm Agent Team Member

Pete Aleman

Office Representative

Pete joined the Joseph Benincasa State Farm Agency here in Farmingdale in 2021. As a graduate of New Jersey City University with a Business of Science Degree and a concentration in Marketing, he began his career in the world of accounting and soon transitioned into insurance. Pete is a licensed Property and Casualty representative who is always willing to assist our customers with their auto, home, and personal articles insurance needs. He is fluent in reading, writing and speaking Spanish and holds a Real Estate license as well. Pete is married to his wife, Jennifer, and together they have a beautiful little girl. He enjoys reading motivational books, watching football and going on road trips. Pete also loves the warm family feeling of our office and the fact that Joe is a hands on agent who will help find a solution to any problem.

Fabrianna Restani State Farm Agent Team Member

Fabrianna Restani

Office Representative

Fabrianna has been a team member with the Joseph Benincasa Office since February 2016. Fabrianna started during her first year of college in a support role to our service team. Fabrianna recently acquired her insurance licenses and is now working in a new role within all of our lines of business. Fabrianna also works in a leadership role in our social media and marketing department.
Available Positions

Click to view all of Joseph's current openings!

Please Note: This opportunity is about potential employment with an independent contractor agent who solicits applications for State Farm products and services, and does NOT result in employment with any of the State Farm Insurance Companies. The employment selection decision , terms and conditions of employment (such as compensation and benefits) are all determined solely by the independent contractor agent.